Bahamas Restaurant Guide
Daniel Mode
Daniel Mode
Laura Schulthies
Laura SchulthiesThe Bahamas are a favorite Caribbean travel destination for American vacationers, and it’s easy to see why. With plentiful sunshine, beautiful beaches, and over 700 islands to choose from, there is something for everyone in this tropical paradise. Here is our guide to the best restaurants in The Bahamas.
This article contains affiliate links. If you click on our links, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. This helps us continue to offer free travel guides, but does not influence our recommendations in any way. Thanks for supporting independent travel content.
Where to Eat
+ click map to enlarge
Eleuthera
This idyllic series of islands is home to around 11,000 residents and is the quintessential Bahamas experience. Popular with ex-pats, fine dining is easy to come by in this beautiful Bahamas region.
New Providence
Around 70 percent of the island population live in New Providence, so it stands to reason that there is some very diverse culinary culture here as well! In addition, it’s one of the cheaper locations for food and accommodation and well worth a visit during your stay. This is also a popular area for all inclusive resorts.
Grand Bahama
If you’re after more of a locals-only vibe, Grand Bahama is the place to be. Look for seafood shacks, secretly hidden beaches, and hole-in-the-wall dining sure to impress even the fussiest eater.
Great Exuma
The Exumas Islands are some of the most beautiful in the Bahamas and home to some of the best local dining you’ll come across. However, while fine dining and trendy restaurants are available, you’re better off seeking out some local institutions for a taste of genuine Caribbean cuisine.
Harbor Island
This island is incredibly popular with those looking for outdoor adventures. Golf, sailing, and skydiving are just some of the great activities you can undertake here – sure to work up an appetite.
Budget Restaurants
Crabs N' Things, New Providence
Located on the beach in New Providence, this seafood shack is popular with locals and tourists alike for its fresh seafood, friendly staff, and great vibe. Stop by for some coconut crab, conch fritters & snapper, or simply have a refreshing alcoholic “sky juice” to relax after a long day of exploring. A word of warning – the portions here are massive, so be prepared!
Daddy Brown’s, Grand Bahama
Also known as Da Conch Man, Daddy Brown’s Conch Stand is one of the best places in Grand Bahama to grab conch-based dishes. You’ll find a mix of locals and tourists lined up on any given day, which should be enough to tell you that this place is legit! While the food isn’t fancy, the flavors are enough to have you coming back for more. Try the fried lobster and conch or sink your teeth into the famous conch salad.
Anchor Bay Fish Fry, Eleuthera
If you like a side of local music with your meal, the Friday night Anchor Bay Fish Fry is the place for you! Tourists and locals flock down to this Eleuthera institution for the vibrant atmosphere and incredible scenery – as well as the high-quality local food! Stop by for some conch fry, then watch the sun go down as street dancing and singing emerge around you.
The New Duff, Nassau
This fun and funky little spot puts a unique Asian street food twist on the traditional Bahamian dessert, guava duff. You’ll love the fluffy, handmade steamed bao buns filled with sweet fillings like caramelized coconut or guava smothered with traditional sauce. Make sure to try The New Duff’s Savory Bao Buns filled with island flavors such as jerk chicken, ginger pork, and curried mutton. You can wash it all down with a traditional bush tea and choose your preferred level of sweetness. We love this iconically Bahamian spot’s irresistible, sweet, and savory fusion.
Angela’s Starfish, Harbor Island
Just 15 minutes walk from the center of town, Angela’s Starfish is a quiet, kitschy backyard eatery that will please even the fussiest eater. Surrounded by roosters and mismatched décor, enjoy giant portions of local classics like conch with peas and rice, or follow your meal with a deliciously sweet piece of Caribbean pineapple cake. Once you’ve finished your meal, settle back for a chat with the friendly staff, and learn all about the history and culture of Harbor Island.
Midrange Restaurants
Athena Cafe, Nassau
Located in downtown Nassau, Athena Café and Bar is one of the most famous Greek eateries in the Bahamas. The café is covered in tasteful white and blue décor and will make you feel like you’ve somehow stepped across the sea into Athens. Settle back with a feta and lamb gyro, shrimp skewers or dolmades, and enjoy the cool sea breeze across your face.
Cappucino’s Italian, Grand Bahama
A traditional Italian restaurant located in the heart of Grand Bahama. Family-owned and operated, Cappucino’s focuses on fresh, quality Italian produce and is the closest thing to eating in Italy without leaving the Bahamas. Try the famously tender filet mignon, or enjoy the delicious pasta Pomodoro and bask in the charming, homely atmosphere of this delightful Mediterranean eatery.
Brigadier’s Restaurant, Andros
Situated next to Dream Villas Resort in Andros, Brigadier’s is famous for its quality international and Caribbean fare and relaxed atmosphere. Enjoy dishes like sizzling crawfish in the modern dining room, or take your food outside to the dock for spectacular views over the ocean.
Santanna’s Bar & Grill, Exuma
Make sure you get to Santanna’s Bar & Grill early, as this seaside eatery always has a line out the “door”! Hungry patrons have choices of traditional and local grilled meats, seafood, and Caribbean-style sides sure to fill a rumbling stomach. The menu’s standout is the crawfish mac and cheese, which is unlike anything found elsewhere in Exuma.
Meze Grill, Nassau
With a beautifully diverse menu and excellent staff this is a must visit while in the Bahamas. Steak, sushi, pasta and more, everyone will be satisfied and happy. You can order take away or eat in, both options are fresh and delightful. Once you try it, you’ll be sure to return.
High-End Restaurants
Dunmore Restaurant, Harbor Island
Chic, beachside dining with a twist. The Dunmore Restaurant is a relaxed, casual eatery with a 60s vibe and accompanying music that showcases the Bahamas of years past. Serving up modern Caribbean fine dining with a Mediterranean twist, this restaurant is the jewel in the crown of The Dunmore Resort and draws hundreds of hungry tourists through the doors every year. Order local dishes like the stone crab tostada or Caribbean poke bowl, which feature some of the freshest Bahaman produce around.
Cafe Matisse, Nassau
You won’t get any closer to dinner in Florence than you will at this New Providence restaurant. Stucco arches, creeping vines, and recreations of Italian artists bring the Mediterranean atmosphere to life, and the food will transport you to Italy with a single bite. From succulent gamberi prawns to the famous calamarata, there is no compromise on quality at Café Matisse.
23 North, Exuma Island
Complementing the barefoot luxury of the beautiful Grand Isle Resort, 23 North offers visitors a sophisticated eating option to lounge on the resort’s grounds. Non-resort guests can access 23 North with a day pass available at the Grand Isle Resort front desk. With a fusion menu that blends Bahamian and Asian fare seamlessly, 23 North is a can’t miss on your next trip to the Bahamas. You can enjoy everything from fresh, local seafood to Caribbean jerk-style dishes and barbecue, all with beautiful ocean views. Make sure to try the conch fritters, the daily catch, and the black angus ribeye. Don’t miss out on the mango rice pudding for dessert!
Flying Fish Gastro Bar, Grand Bahama
For lively music, quality food, and unbelievable ocean views, look no further than Flying Fish Gastro Pub. With an ever-changing seasonal menu and specials showcasing produce caught that day, it’s no wonder that this is one of the most popular restaurants on the island. Chef Tim Tibbits effortlessly pairs spicy chicken curry with their signature grilled calamari and stone crab cakes for a gastronomical experience not soon to be forgotten.
Dune, Paradise Island
For an award-winning meal overlooking the turquoise waters of Paradise Bay, make your way to Dune. The British Colonial architecture is a stark contrast with the innovative French-Asian fusion served by Chef Jean-Georges, and every inch of the venue screams luxury. The Black Truffle with Three Cheese & Farm Egg is one of the most unique dishes on the menu and goes hand-in-hand with fresh salads and raw options like yellowfin tuna tartare. For a more relaxed experience, enjoy unique cocktails and vintage wines at the beachfront bar.
More
CARIBBEAN
The Bahamas has something for everyone, whether you’re a single wanting to get away, a couple needing quality time to connect, or a family seeking adventure. With 700 islands and 2,500 cays, the opportunities are endless!
The Bahamas are a beautiful stretch of islands in the northern Caribbean. With white sand beaches, turquoise water and numerous islands to choose from, there's something for everyone. Here are some of the best hotels in the Bahamas.
The Bahamas has everything you could desire for a perfect tropical getaway; a warm climate, sparkling blue waters and friendly locals. Here are the best all-inclusive resorts in the Bahamas that you should definitely look into.
The Bahamas is known for having some of the most beautiful beaches in the world. The gorgeous turquoise waters and warm ivory sand can even be seen from space! Here is our guide to the best beaches in the Bahamas to enjoy this tropical paradise.
Packing for beach vacations shouldn’t be hard, so we’ve put together a unique beach vacation packing list to help and included some of our favorite items. From clothes to electronics and everything in between, we've got all the tips to make packing a breeze.
Welcome to beautiful Antigua! This stunning Caribbean Island has been a favorite of holidaymakers from around the world for years, with its relaxed culture and gorgeous seafood just two of the biggest draws for travelers looking to embrace the slower side of life.
Aruba is a small slice of paradise in the Caribbean and is filled with various restaurants and cuisine options to suit any traveler. From budget-friendly ‘mom and pop’ restaurants to high-end mouthwatering dishes, it’s hard to go hungry in Aruba.
Known for its beautiful shores and friendly locals, the Cayman Islands combine wild adventure, stunning scenery, and delicious food. Here is our guide to the best Cayman Island restaurants you'll have to check out on your visit!
As a pristine and beachy oasis, the Dominican Republic is perfect for a budget-friendly tropical getaway. From local Caribbean dishes to authentic Italian cuisine, the food selection is delicious and diverse. Here are some of the best restaurants in the Dominican Republic!
Known for its relaxed vibes and vibrant music scene, Jamaica is one of the best choices for those looking for a laid-back getaway. From bbq street stalls to beachside dining, there is a Jamaica restaurant for everyone on this island paradise.
Puerto Rico has something to offer every traveler. Its sun-filled beaches, traditional cuisine and rum-filled nightlife are the biggest attractions for most tourists to this beautiful island. There are food options for everyone here, whether you love pork, seafood, or margaritas.
Located in the Caribbean Sea, St. Barthelemy, or St. Bart’s, is a go-to destination for luxury holidaymakers looking to blow off steam. The cuisine choices are expansive with something delicious for everyone. Here are some of the best restaurants in St. Barts!